So You Lost Your Porsche on a Burning Boat. Now What?

It’s a car person’s nightmare: The special Bentley or Lamborghini you ordered a half-year back—or more—is finally on a cargo ship headed your way. Then the ship catches fire.

The nightmare became reality on Feb. 16 when a vessel sailing from Germany to Rhode Island caught fire near the Azores with more than $400 million worth of autos aboard, including luxury models from Bentley, Porsche, and Lamborghini. A daring rescue by the Portugal’s Air Force and Navy saved all 22 crew members, with no reported injuries.

As of Feb. 22, the Felicity Ace remained ablaze; what remains of an estimated 4,000 Volkswagen AG vehicles will be assessed once a salvage team can properly inspect the nearly ship, whose length is three football fields. A website has been set up to provide updates on the incident.

For those with ordered vehicles aboard, there’s really just one question: What do I do about my car?

Ship Happens

A cargo ship going down with cars on board is not such an unusual phenomenon: At least eight major incidents involving large boats and damaged cars have occurred since 2002. In 2019, the Grande America destined for Brazil sank with 37 Porsches aboard, including four rare, highly customized 911 GT2 RS (average price today: $366,487, and specialized ones can approach $800,000).

That same year, a ship called the Golden Ray departed the port of Brunswick, Ga., before it capsized with more than 4,000 vehicles bound for the Middle East, including trucks and SUVs from General Motors and Mercedes-Benz.

In a 2002 incident, an empty German cargo ship hit the submerged hull of a sunken car carrier, the Tricolor, in the English Channel. The Norwegian-flagged ship contained an estimated £30 million ($40.6 million) worth of high-performance vehicles onboard, including hundreds of cars from BMW, Saab, and Volvo. At the time of the incident, a spokesman for BMW said the company was most worried about the cars’ chassis numbers falling into the wrong hands; chassis numbers are lucrative currency among car thieves.

Executives at Volvo were more concerned that none of the cars was salvageable.

“You can’t possibly get a car back into a fit state once it’s been in salt water,” Volvo’s U.K. products services manager, John Rawlings, said after the accident. “We have to think of the effect on our prestige image of selling these things.”

Former merchant mariner Sal Mercogliano said that in the case of Felicity Ace, damage to all of the vehicles is likely because it would be difficult for firefighters to get into the tightly packed cargo decks to fight the flames.

“The potential now is with the ship being abandoned, the fire will rage out of control and jump from vehicle to vehicle,” Mercogliano said in a YouTube video about the blaze. “Vehicles don’t explode … but vehicles burn. The fire will run the length of this vessel and potentially gut it.”

No cause of fire has been confirmed.

Keep Going? Or Cut Losses?

So what is the recourse for clients who have been expecting these cars? Technically, the vehicles don’t belong to the customers until delivery. They still belong to the automaker, so personal automotive insurance won’t be engaged. Commercial insurance policies for auto manufacturers and the cargo companies would address their losses. Volkswagen Group maintains vendor relationships for shipping cars, not for each individual VW brand, a spokesperson says.

Those unfortunate souls with vehicles lost at sea thus have two options in general: Resubmit the order for the vehicle, keep the deposit in place, and wait months for a fresh shipment. Or cut their loses, emotionally and financially, take the disaster as a sign of some sort, and order something altogether different.

“The dealer has promised to keep me posted with any updates on how Porsche decides to sort this out,” customer Matt Farah tweeted about the customized Porsche Boxster Spyder he had ordered in August 2021 and which was on the Felicity Ace. “Odds are a new build—and hopefully, not another eight months wait for it.”

Good Customer Service

In the case of luxury vehicles, it behooves automakers such as Bentley, Porsche, and Lamborghini to do what they can to placate their high net worth clients. Manufacturers don’t want those $300,000 orders going elsewhere; those who spend that much cash on a rare vehicle are often lifelong brand loyalists — or aspire to be. That is what Porsche did with the Golden Ray incident.

“In a special decision and to uphold its commitment to its valued Brazilian customers, Porsche has ensured that those [911 GT2 RS] units will be reproduced in the order in which they were originally confirmed,” the company stated at the time. The move to reproduce cars in the same order as they had been intended is extremely rare, requiring ample time and money — and delays for other vehicles.

In the instance of the Felicity Ace, Porsche will take similar measures.

“We are already working to replace every car affected by this incident,” Porsche spokesperson Marcus Kabel said in an email. “The cars will be as close as possible to their original, ordered specification.” All told, the fire is expected to pose a $155 million total loss for the brands affected.

The cost of the car itself, which for American buyers would be the initial deposit, rather than the whole MSRP, since the car had yet to be delivered, would transition to a new car, if ordered, Kabel said. If the order is cancelled, Porsche will refund the deposit, “although based on feedback from customers, most are looking forward to receiving reordered vehicles,” he said.

“On the details of the specific cases, this is between the dealer and the customer,” he said, Since all Porsche dealerships are independently owned and operated. “We are working to expedite the delivery of a replacement vehicle as soon as possible. We are working on this as a priority; the first cars will be built soon.”

A Lamborghini spokesperson declined to comment on how the Italian brand would handle the losses. A Bentley representative confirmed that 189 Bentley vehicles are on board the ship and that the customer cars will take priority for replacement. Both manufacturers face a potentially bigger loss than Porsche, proportionately speaking, since they make far fewer, and far more expensive, vehicles.

For Farah, the best decision in this case was to reorder his same spec. “[Porsche] gave me the opportunity to make changes to the build, and I said, ‘Build it like I ordered it the first time,'” he said. Farah was unable to confirm how long the new build would take but said that Porsche told him it was “a priority.” In the meantime, he’ll drive something else.

But for Danielle Tringali, who had ordered a Porsche Macan last December—and now finds the Macan is still adrift in the Atlantic—it wasn’t a foregone conclusion. Tringali remained undecided for much of the week about the best course of action before ultimately deciding Feb. 23 to wait it out for a new Macan.

“My car has been reordered and in production,” Tringali said. “Estimated end-of-June delivery sadly, though.”