Bills Aimed at Property Claims Litigation Expected in Texas Legislative Session

Texas lawmakers are expected to file legislation this year aimed at stemming the tide of property claims litigation in the wake of catastrophic weather events, such as hailstorms.

Proponents of such legislation would like to see a measure that limits the time in which claims over property losses may be filed, similar to the limitations put in place for the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association after it was inundated with claims-related lawsuits following Hurricane Ike.

By the end of 2008, TWIA, the residual market for insuring seacoast properties for wind and hail, figured it had enough resources available to pay claims for both Hurricane Ike and Hurricane Dolly that hit the Texas coast that year.

That was before it was hit with numerous large class-action lawsuits over its handling of Ike and Dolly claims. The cost of those lawsuits ran into the hundreds of millions of dollars and forced TWIA into a precarious financial situation.

In response to TWIA’s many troubles, the Texas Legislature in 2011 passed a reform measure, House Bill 3, which, among other things, limited the time frame in which claims litigation may be brought against the association and the extent of damages that may be awarded.

As the potential for more TWIA Ike claim litigation started winding down, enterprising plaintiffs’ attorneys started looking to the state’s inevitable and frequent hail storms for opportunities to increase payouts and initiate claims litigation, insurance industry professionals say.

In response, the industry is pressing for TWIA-like claims limitation legislation during this legislative session to address the problem of “long tail” hail claims resulting from what they say is questionable litigation and the aggressive actions of public adjusters.

Hail Aplenty

Texas notoriously experiences some of the most extreme weather events — including hailstorms — in the United States year after year.

“Texas leads the nation in the number of hail events experienced each year. In 2013, that number was 651, nearly 150 more than Kansas, the second most-afflicted state. Since 2000, Texas has been home to 20 percent of the nation’s hail claim losses,” wrote Ian Adams with Right Street Blog in an Oct. 2, 2014, post on Insurance Journal.com.

In the past few years, communities across the state have been hit with hail storms of significant size and corresponding losses.

A massive hailstorm in Amarillo in May 2013 covered 75 percent of the city and resulted in $500 million in insured losses, according to the Insurance Council of Texas.

Hailstorms in 2014 in Alice, in South Texas, and in Denton and Abilene in the north, racked up losses in the hundreds of millions of dollars in each of those locations.

And claims amounts keep climbing, largely due to litigation, insurance professionals say.

‘Ike Contingent’ Pounding Insurers with Texas Hail Claims

Hidalgo County in the Rio Grande Valley, which has been hit with major hailstorms in recent years, has been a hot spot for claim litigation, according to Mark Hanna, a spokesman for the Insurance Council of Texas.

On average, the percent of hail claims that turn into lawsuits is 2 percent, Hanna said in an email to Insurance Journal.

“In Hidalgo County, it became 40 percent,” Hanna said.

A similar situation has developed following significant hailstorms in North Texas.

Tort reform advocacy groups and the insurance industry have been working on potential legislation to address the growing problem of property loss litigation, according to Lee Loftis, government affairs director for the Independent Insurance Agents of Texas.

“The IIAT has been working with the Texans for Lawsuit Reform, the Texas Civil Justice League and Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse for over a year now,” Loftis said during a presentation at the IIAT’s Joe E. Vincent Management Seminar in Austin in late January.

While the insurance industry has been involved, the advocacy groups will be the ones to take the lead in this legislation, Loftis said.

Similarly, Texans for Lawsuit Reform and other groups led the successful push for medical malpractice lawsuit reform legislation that capped the amount of jury awards for noneconomic damages in Texas.

“What we are trying to do is make sure they understand the urgency of it and get them the information that they need to move forward,” Loftis said.

He added that to his knowledge a bill had not been filed yet but that the process was moving in that direction.

Loftis said many IIAT member agents in the affected areas have communicated to the association that “public adjusters are as big a problem” as litigators.

Whether are not to address the activities of public adjusters in any proposed legislation is being discussed, he said.

“Don’t know whether it will happen or not,” Loftis said.